Selecting the Right Literature Review Method for Design Science Research: Insights from Tichaona Chinyerere
At the ACIST Conference 2024 in Harare, Tichaona Chinyerere, a PhD candidate in Information Systems at the University of Cape Town, presented a compelling exploration of the literature review methodologies best suited for Design Science Research (DSR). His research sheds light on the challenges doctoral candidates face when navigating the complex array of literature review options in this innovative research paradigm.
Addressing the Literature Review Dilemma in Design Science Research
Design Science Research (DSR) is recognised for its ability to generate actionable knowledge and solutions within the field of Information Systems (IS). However, as doctoral researchers embrace DSR, they often encounter difficulties in selecting the most appropriate literature review method to support their studies.
Chinyerere’s research addresses this critical gap by analysing literature review types used in a selection of DSR-focused doctoral theses and dissertations. His findings reveal that descriptive literature reviews dominate the field, with their primary aim being theory building.
The Case for a Hermeneutic Approach
To align more closely with the objectives of DSR, Chinyerere advocates for the use of the hermeneutic literature review method. This approach emphasises:
Interpretation and understanding: Encouraging deeper engagement with existing research to uncover insights that inform problem-solving.
Alignment with DSR principles: Supporting the iterative, solution-focused nature of design science by facilitating a richer understanding of the theoretical and practical context.
Key Insights for Doctoral Researchers
Chinyerere argues that selecting the appropriate literature review method is vital to the success of doctoral studies in DSR. His presentation highlighted the challenges doctoral candidates face in navigating literature review methodologies. It also provided a comparative analysis of prevalent methods, such as descriptive reviews, in DSR theses and advocated for the hermeneutic approach as a means to achieve deeper theoretical alignment and problem-solving effectiveness.
Advancing Research Excellence in Design Science
Chinyerere’s work underscores the importance of methodological rigour and relevance in doctoral research. By guiding future scholars in making informed decisions about their literature review methods, his research contributes to advancing the academic and practical impact of DSR within Information Systems.
–Tichaona Chinyerere
